Why is this Printful vs Printify comparison not typical? Usually, all comparisons boil down to Printful’s unambiguous leader, while Printify is always present but does not reach the leader. Thus, everything will be precisely the opposite in this scenario.
Printful has in-house printers, while Printify is just another middleman in the chain from manufacturer to customer. But who cares? It’s a business, and to make the right decision, you have to rely on many aspects instead of sympathies to one or another company.
Printful and Printify are the two largest Print-On-Demand (POD) companies for designers. They offer many similarities and some significant differences that may sway your decision about which to use. We’ll take a look at what Printful and Printify can do and how they compare so you can make the best decision possible for your business.
What’s Better Printful or Printify?
Printful and Printify are two of the most popular print-on-demand flagships. They have been in business for a while, both with thousands of satisfied customers.
The question is should you use Printful or Printify?
I won’t give you a precise answer – use this or use that! It’s a decision you must make for yourself, so keep reading this Printful vs Printify review to make the best choice.
What Exactly is POD (Print-On-Demand)?
As the name implies, print-on-demand is an online fulfillment method in which the seller collaborates with a supplier to create custom-printed items on an order-by-order basis.
The supplier, primarily a print-on-demand service with a warehouse and an online platform connecting with the drop shipper’s online selling channel, customizes white-label items with the seller’s brand or a customer’s pre-made print design.
Caps, t-shirts, tote bags, leggings, hoodies, cushions, and curtains are among the items available. This list could go on and on.
The concept, like drop shipping, allows you to avoid holding inventory or paying upfront costs until a product is sold to a consumer. Because it has cheap overheads and a low barrier to entry, it is the most excellent choice for testing a business idea.
If you’ve developed a following organically or through marketing, print-on-demand is a viable alternative for monetizing your material.
Because you don’t have to deal with the fulfillment process, it’s easy to build a revenue stream.
So, let’s take a closer look at both services to see which one is ideal for you.
How Printify Works
Printify makes every effort to make the order automation process as simple as possible.
Its extensive product catalog is comparable to that of its competitor. In addition, you may personalize your print designs to appear on t-shirts, sweatshirts, mugs, canvas prints, leggings, and other items.
The ability to handpick your supplier is beneficial to both your company and your consumers. As a dropshipping company, you can protect your brand’s authority by partnering with the best print provider.
You have the option of requesting samples. It allows you to feel and rate the product’s quality and print design firsthand. Then, if you like what you see, you may go to the next stage and list the various products in your store.
Printify, like its main competition, employs a mockup generator to alleviate the work of developing print designs. In addition, it includes simple drag-and-drop capabilities that are highly user-friendly for newbies.
Printify has every color option imaginable for creating a 3D high-quality product image. There is also an extensive product selection to choose from.
The POD service collaborates with print designers and companies that employ cutting-edge technology to increase the overall quality of their products.
Printify organizes these print-on-demand experts by bestseller, region, and pricing. Choosing the proper print supplier to fulfill your orders is a valuable addition to your POD dropshipping business.
And, as predicted, Printify handles the entire fulfillment procedure – to get out of the deficit, the print-on-demand service guarantees to meet all order management priorities.
When you make a transaction, be ensure that quality control is in place and that you can track each shipment.
All that remains is for you to decide on a marketing plan. In terms of method of operation, Printify appears to be one of the leaders.
Best Printify Print Providers
Printify has a convenient print provider ranking system in place. In a nutshell, pick print suppliers based on Printify’s ranking.
Printify’s Ranking Explained
The choice of a print-on-demand service directly influences how some of your business’s essential aspects will be fulfilled. It’s because quality, rapid fulfillment times, and reliable delivery are characteristics of a well-established print-on-demand firm.
Choosing a print supplier may not always feel as essential at the time, primarily since it occurs immediately before creating your items, which is exciting. As a result, it is critical to make these judgments in the most transparent manner feasible.
That is why Printify designed a method for you to make these critical decisions as soon and as efficiently as possible. A technique for you to rapidly select the best print supplier to assure that the decision you make is sound.
Printify’s Print Provider Ranking allows you to easily pick the appropriate print provider based on your requirements while also considering the print quality and production timeframes.
Your only job is to select the product you want to sell from the vast array of items available on the Printify platform and click on it to view the Print Providers and their rankings.
Printify developed an algorithm that helps to continually rate every Print Provider offered on the Printify platform and ensures that the rankings are always up to date.
What Exactly is the Print Provider Ranking?
The Print Provider rating is determined by the Product Reprint Ratio, Delayed Production Time, and User Appraisals. Simply put, a compound score is determined after the Print Provider’s time to finish an order; a total number of reprints and interaction with users and suppliers are all taken into account.
It is the most effective approach to assess the quality of the print provider’s services while reading the comments of other vendors.
Furthermore, the Print Provider Rankings are displayed by order of individual Print Provider for each product for your convenience. It shows immediately after clicking on the product you want to sell and scrolling to check which Print Provider has the goods available.
Each Print Provider’s name is accompanied by a numerical score, indicating their Print Provider Ranking score. Their numerical score represents their entire ranking.
To make an educated selection, you need carefully evaluate the rating before placing orders. To make things simpler for you, after selecting the product you want to sell, click on the “Sort by” feature, followed by “Printify ranking,” which enables you to filter the Print list Providers so that they begin with the highest-ranked Print Providers.
Can I Sway Printify’s Print Provider Rankings?
Printify merchants may impact print suppliers’ ratings in a variety of ways. Leaving comments on your tester order is an effective method to influence these scores.
When you receive your tester order, you will be able to rate your Print Provider on a scale of 1-5 stars. After you place your sample order, a more detailed review box will appear where you may put down your thoughts in addition to providing general feedback regarding the Print Provider’s quality and fulfillment timeliness.
While Print Provider Rankings are a quick method to find the best print-on-demand firm to deal with, you also need to research brands, colors, pricing, shipping rates, production times, and delivery timeframes.
While Printify strives to quickly assist you in making an educated selection, as your business grows, you will want more technical information when selecting the best print-on-demand businesses for your business.
How Printful Works
Printful has production facilities in the United States, Mexico, and Europe (Latvia). To ensure that clients’ purchases are filled on time, the firm serves a wide geographical area.
To get started, join up for Printful and link your shop. Why should you connect your shop to this POD service? Print-on-demand is correctly referred to like any other drop shipping technique. Once you’ve completed all of the integrations, you’ll need to work on your unique goods utilizing the mockup generator.
What exactly is a mockup generator? Technically, the mockup generator is more of a design tool that allows you to generate bespoke prints for your listed items visually. In addition, it enables you to produce stunning, high-resolution photographs by utilizing the provided templates.
On Printful, you may browse any of its categories and select any of its POD goods to publish to your online store. There are more than 200 items to choose from.
There are thousands of goods to list on your dropshipping business. Because of its vast number of unique branding choices, Printful provides consumers with a multifaceted approach.
After you’ve created your mockups, Printful allows you to import all of the product designs into your shop. The following step is to market your items to your target audience while waiting for the order automation function to kick in.
Printful, like Printify, prints, packs, and delivers all orders placed via your business. Before the order is delivered, the drop shipper must pay for the fulfillment expenses.
It relieves you of the burden of manually developing a print design and sending orders to your clients.
When Printful vs Printify is compared, their operating methods appear to be pretty similar.
Printify vs Printful Paid Features
Printify and Printful both have premium features. And this is where Printify clearly outperforms Printful. If Printify provides valuable options, it appears like Printful is attempting to imitate Printify and is just collecting some random features and trying to sell them.
Printify’s premium plan offers up to a 20% discount on all goods. It’s beneficial, especially if you sell 500 or more goods each month.
Printful simply gathered a slew of supplementary tools that all print-on-demand merchants already have, made one of their functions paid and one of their paid features free.
According to the foregoing, I may infer that Printify provides value simultaneously that Printful is ripping you off, or, to put it another way, Printful’s premium features do not provide value.
Printful vs Printify Product Pricing
Printify outperforms Printful in this category as well. I’m not going to go into all of the product pricing, but let’s compare the Bella+Canvas 3001 t-shirt.
Printful costs are significantly greater. For example, Bella+Canvas 3001 t-shirt with print starts at $12.74 excluding VAT.
Printify prices are much more seller-friendly. For example, on Printify, the identical t-shirt costs $7.64 or even $6.68 for Premium users.
It’s a significant price gap, and the Bella+Canvas t-shirt is not the only product with such a disparity.
Printify is the way to go when it comes to product pricing!
Printify vs Printful Integrations
In this category, Printful beats Printify with 19:7
Printful integrates with Amazon, Etsy, eBay, Wish, WooCommerce, Shopify, Square, Wix, Squarespace, Webflow, Ecwid, BigCommerce, PrestaShop, Weebly, Big Cartel, Magento, Storenvy, 3dcart, and Launch Cart.
Printify has integrations with Etsy, eBay, WooCommerce, PrestaShop, BigCommerce, Wix, and Shopify.
A brief summary of the eCommerce platforms with which Printful and Printify integrate.
Etsy is not a platform where you can create a solo store like Shopify. It’s a business. Marketplaces allow you to add your goods to an existing popular website. It increases your visibility, but you must compete with other merchants. If you already have an online business and want to sell on another channel, or if you wish to sell on a marketplace, this is an attractive option.
Etsy is simple to use and gets you up and running quickly. Etsy has 40 million consumers globally, so you may reach a larger audience and attract new customers. There are no monthly fees for using Etsy; however, there is a 5% fee on all transactions and shipping, and publishing items costs $0.20, which must be renewed every four months. It also includes seller regulations and limited customization choices for how your business looks. Printful’s interface with Etsy does not provide actual shipping costs; thus, you must enter them manually. However, it is still simple to set up and add items.
So, should you take advantage of this platform? We believe that Etsy is excellent for merchants who want to sell on well-established marketplaces and don’t mind the limits on personalization.
Amazon is one of the most prominent online marketplaces and is trusted by millions of customers. And, like Etsy, it’s an excellent alternative if you already have an online business and want to sell on another channel or if you’re going to sell only on Amazon.
You’ll be selling on a renowned, established platform with worldwide marketplaces if you choose Amazon, but we feel there are certain drawbacks. For example, Amazon has a complex setup and tight seller regulations, such as what sort of product photographs you may include and how quickly you must ship out your items, among other things. And it requires some effort not only to put it up but also to keep it running.
To sell on Amazon using Printful, you’ll need a professional Seller account, which costs $39.99 a month and includes fees of up to 15% on each sale.
Printful and Amazon are more challenging to connect than any of our other integrations. Because live shipping costs aren’t accessible, you’ll have to enter them manually. However, you can automatically add your items using our product push generator, and we have a step-by-step tutorial to help you get started.
So, do you want to go with Amazon? Yes, if you’re going to sell on one of the world’s most popular and reputable marketplaces and have the time to study and obey Amazon’s regulations.
Squarespace is a well-known design-oriented platform well-known for its clean, essential, and completely responsive website templates. Squarespace allows you to construct aesthetically appealing businesses by utilizing its extensive theme library. In addition, they provide many marketing options such as trackable advertisements, email campaigns, and 24/7 customer service, among other things.
Printful’s connection with Squarespace is simple, although it does require some effort to set up. There are no current shipping prices; therefore, you must enter them manually. There is also no product push, so you will need to create your goods on Squarespace and then sync them with Printful. Printful is only available to Squarespace plan subscribers.
What is our last word on Squarespace? It’s the platform for you if you want to establish a distinctive, aesthetically appealing online store and aren’t frightened of manually configuring the integration.
eBay is one of the few industry leaders with more than 20 years of eCommerce expertise, with over 167 million monthly visitors.
eBay is excellent for people who currently have a business and want to expand their sales channels. However, it, like Amazon, has a convoluted system and stringent seller restrictions. It also requires some work to set up and maintain. Creating an account on eBay is free, and there are no membership costs; however, they do charge a 10% commission on any sales made on their site and a $0.35 listing fee. Although there are no active rates with Printful’s integration, you may add goods using our product push generator. However, connecting to eBay is complex, and new users are restricted in terms of the product variations they may post and the overall product value they can give.
You should only explore eBay if you are serious about reaching a wider audience and are willing to devote time to it.
WooCommerce is a plugin for WordPress, a well-known and well-respected content management system.
WooCommerce, unlike the other platforms, does not offer to host. Instead, it’s completely configurable, so you may set it up whatever you like, but you’ll need some technical knowledge to do so. Aside from the cost of hosting, utilizing WooCommerce is free.
Printful’s connection with WooCommerce is fully automated—live shipping prices are accessible, and goods may be added using our product generator. Of course, there’s a lot you can modify, so that setup may take some time; but, it’s not as tricky as our other integrations.
So, how about WooCommerce for your online store? WooCommerce is your best choice if you want a free, popular, and completely configurable platform built on a trustworthy content management system, especially if you currently use WordPress. Just bear in mind that it’s rather technical, and it will take some time to set up your own hosting.
Storenvy is a pre-built marketplace that focuses on social sharing. It has a marketplace as well as the opportunity to set up your store. It’s simple to use and completely free. However, because your shop will be using Storenvy’s default theme and a dedicated domain, there will be less space for personalization. In addition, while Storenvy is free to use, you will be charged a 15% commission on marketplace purchases.
Although Printful’s integration does not offer actual shipping costs, you can quickly add your items using our product push generator.
What is Storenvy’s bottom line? Storenvy is the ideal choice if you want a free, easy-to-use platform with a built-in marketplace and don’t mind the limits on customization.
PrestaShop is a free, open-source eCommerce platform with a slew of additional features to help your business thrive. It comprises tools for implementing SEO tactics, managing orders, and collecting statistics on marketing performance.
PrestaShop does not include hosting, but it does provide additional customization options for your store. That also implies that it needs a bit more technical know-how and time to produce. Although there are no active rates in Printful’s integration, you may add items using the push generator.
If you want a free, adaptable, and popular platform to launch your store and are willing to set up your own hosting, PrestaShop is a good option.
BigCommerce supports multi-channel selling, allowing you to sell on your website and marketplaces and social media sites like Pinterest and Facebook. It’s simple to use, comes with hosting, and has excellent customer service.
Although the Printful integration does not offer actual shipping costs, you may add goods using our push generator. It is simple to set up. Subscriptions start at $29.95 a month, and you can get a free trial first.
If you want a hosted solution that allows you to sell on third-party channels and is willing to pay monthly fees, this integration is for you.
The focus of Big Cartel is on artists. Big Cartel makes it simple to set up your business, and the platform itself is straightforward to use. Its main selling point is that it is free if you sell five or fewer goods. However, if you add more goods, you will be charged a monthly membership fee.
It is straightforward and quick to connect Big Cartel with Printful. However, there are no current shipping rates or product push generators, so you’ll have to configure your shipping and items manually.
If you want to work with a platform that honors artists and their work, you should utilize Big Cartel. In addition, a big Cartel is an excellent alternative if you’re going to sell on a smaller scale, and manually adding items to your site is not an issue.
Wish is one of the most popular mobile marketplaces because it aims to make buying enjoyable. It is the most popular shopping app in 42 countries, with over 500 million users worldwide. Wish is free to join, and there are no subscription or listing fees. When a product is ordered, you merely pay a portion of the sale.
The Wish platform isn’t the most complicated to set up, but it’s also not the easiest. You will be able to use Printful’s product push feature, but there will be no live rates. Wish has stringent fulfillment deadlines, with each order having to be shipped out within five days after the purchase date. Because Printful wants to ensure on-time delivery for your purchases, the items you may offer on the site will be limited.
If you want to try your hand at selling on a marketplace with a bit of financial commitment and are willing to put in a bit extra effort to set it up, Wish is the way to go. Wish is an excellent method to enter the rapidly expanding mobile commerce sector.
Ecwid facilitates sales across various platforms. For example, you may build your store or quickly integrate a shopping cart into an existing website.
So, with Ecwid, you can embed shopping carts on social media networks such as Facebook and Tumblr and marketplaces such as Google Shopping and manage them all from a single control panel. Ecwid charges recurring monthly fees that begin at $15 per month.
Printful and Ecwid integration is quick and easy, with actual shipping prices and product push features that make it simple to add items.
If you’re okay with recurring fees and wish to sell on various channels, or if you want to add a “purchase” button to an existing website, Ecwid is a good option.
Weebly is an excellent platform for small to medium-sized business owners with little to no technical knowledge. It’s user-friendly and straightforward to set up.
It offers one of the most user-friendly drag-and-drop site builders on the market, as well as a plethora of configurable themes and page layouts. Weebly has a free version for creating items, but you must utilize one of their paid plans to post them on your shop.
It takes only a few minutes to set up Printful with Weebly. You may add your items using our push generator, but because Weebly does not use Printful’s live prices, you will have to set up shipping manually.
If technology isn’t your strong suit and you don’t mind manually tweaking delivery costs, try Weebly.
Gumroad is a simple platform that allows you to sell items on your website, simply including a “purchase” button on any page. It essentially allows you to add the purchasing capability to any shop without any technical knowledge.
It’s simple to set up but doesn’t allow for much customization. You can pay 8.5 percent plus $0.30 for each transaction or $10 per month for a membership.
Although Printful and Gumroad are quick, there are no current shipping prices and no product push generator.
What are your final thoughts? If you’re not keen on customizing and have an existing website that you only want to add a “purchase” button to, Gumroad will come in useful.
ShipStation is third-party software that connects you to platforms that aren’t directly connected with Printful. You’ll be able to submit orders to Printful from other ShipStation integrations, such as Yahoo and Walmart, with the ShipStation connection.
It’s a little more challenging to set up, and you’ll need to ensure that the platform you’re interested in can be connected to ShipStation. After clicking, you will be able to see a list of all of your orders on Shipstation. Monthly memberships start at $9 a month, depending on your order volume.
If you utilize a platform that Printful does not directly interface with and don’t mind working with your orders manually, consider ShipStation.
Magento is the undisputed king of open-source platforms, boasting a solid toolset and a passionate user community. Its sophisticated features make it an excellent alternative for expanding organizations and corporations. Magento provides two choices. Magento Open Source is ideal for small businesses seeking an accessible, professional, and adaptable solution. Magento Commerce is a premium alternative for customers seeking an enterprise-level solution.
The Magento Open Source version is free to use, but you’ll need to locate hosting to utilize it for your business, and the integration takes time to set up. Magento Commerce is designed for experienced sellers, so the price starts at $20,000 per year.
Setting up a store with Magento takes some effort, but it allows you complete flexibility. It should be noted that product push is available, but there are no live rates.
Consider Magento if you are a significant merchant or a developer that understands how to maximize the Magento Open Source version.
Inktale is an online marketplace that makes it as simple as possible for artists to sell their designs on print products—becoming a vendor only takes a few clicks.
You pick your profit for a product using Inktale and don’t have to deal with any payments at all. There are no up-front or monthly expenses, and Inktale handles printing, shipping, and customer service for you. Printful has collaborated with Inktale to print and dispatch all orders. It’s a user-friendly marketplace that gives sales statistics and customer information, but it’s restricted in customization and only offers a few pre-selected product types.
If you want a basic, easy-to-use platform free and don’t mind product and shop page modification limits, Inktale is a good option.
I’ve already stated why I believe Shopify isn’t the superb option: “Shopify is not the best solution for print-on-demand sellers at all.”
Shopify is one of the most well-known eCommerce systems. Its primary selling point is that it is one of the easiest platforms to use while being very configurable.
Shopify’s setup is straightforward. It has an easy-to-use UI and a competent customer service team that will look after you. Shopify has a monthly membership that starts at $29, and each plan has varying credit card charges. The good thing is that they provide a 14-day free trial period.
Printful’s Shopify integration is one of our most automated integrations, and it’s quick and straightforward to set up. It enables simple shipment configuration with live carrier-calculated prices during checkout. It’s also simple to add goods to your store – you can use our Design Maker to design your products, and they’ll appear on your Shopify store and sync with Printful immediately.
Is Shopify right for you? If you want an intuitive, well-rounded platform, you are ready to spend a little more for greater ease.
Printful vs Printify for Etsy
If you’re seeking the best Print On Demand for Etsy, both providers offer straightforward integration with this marketplace. I utilize Printify as a partner, but I’m not going to convince you that you have to do the same. To select the best Print On Demand for Etsy, you must first compare Printful vs Printify and then decide.
Printify vs Printful Fulfillment and Shipping Costs
Printful is a slight step ahead in this area simply because it has a dedicated page that provides complete information about the whole Printful shipping and fulfillment process.
From my own experience, you can’t really rely on what they say about Printful shipping time and processing periods on their website. Not once have I nearly lost eBay clients because Printful’s processing time was far longer than promised.
If shipment takes much longer than expected, your company risks experiencing delayed sales. Printful describes the complete fulfillment procedure in detail.
The procedure begins immediately once an order is placed. Printful estimates that clothing goods can take 2-7 business days to manufacture, while non-apparel products can take 2-5 business days.
Shipping costs vary depending on where the merchandise must be delivered. Printful estimates that it will take around four business days on average. Printful meets its annual objective of over 3 million orders by collaborating with worldwide carrier firms.
FedEx, DHL, USPS.com, and DPD are among the shipping companies featured. In addition, the firm provides comprehensive instruction on how to determine shipping prices.
For print items such as T-shirts, long sleeve shirts, crop tops, and tank tops, your buyers will need to pay the following as shipping:
The first product:
$3.99 in the United States
$4.39 in Europe
$6.49 in Canada
Australia/New Zealand: $6.99
Rest of the World: $5.99
$1.09 in Europe
$1.25 in Canada
$1.25 for Australia/New Zealand
$1.25 for the entire world
You have the option of allowing the consumer to calculate shipping at checkout or include it in the retail price. Customs costs may also apply based on your customer’s geographical region.
Printify also uses top transportation firms to fulfill orders. In addition, the firm has worked with local fulfillment companies to efficiently serve drop shippers selling items from all over the world. Some of these solutions, however, have slightly higher rates.
Because Printify has fewer fulfillment locations, shipping methods take longer to deliver foreign orders. The following is a breakdown of the shipping times:
7-15 business days in the United States
Canada: ten to fifteen business days
International shipping takes 10-30 days.
Printify doesn’t say anything about how long it takes to make a product. Printful, on the other hand, changes the shipping prices during the checkout process in real-time.
To balance the scales, Printify provides a quicker option for retailers on the Advanced Shopify plan.
Printful vs Printify Customer Support
Printify wins in this area, even though Printful engages with its consumers in a more snappy manner.
It’s not about interacting or other gimmicks. Printful or Printify, or any POD platform’s support is typically kind and helpful. But, in the end, it’s always about how quickly they can fix the problem.
Printify performs at a high level, their customer service is competent, and they do not blame other parties for their difficulties. Here’s an explanation of what I mean: Printful blame others.
Printify vs Printful Overall Features
Printful features a well-organized structure that categorizes its offerings succinctly. In addition, Printful’s eCommerce photography service is a notable aspect that is seldom found on other print-on-demand platforms.
Printful has you covered if you require high-resolution pictures to help you develop your brand’s character.
Printful’s automated order processing technology guarantees same-day fulfillment for orders placed before noon. The best feature is its pricing calculator, which assists customers in setting competitive retail prices. But, as said before, it does not always work.
Printify, on the other hand, has an extensive product selection. When it comes to design services, on the other hand, stuff hits the fan. Printful rises to the occasion with graphic design solutions for business branding, marketing, and accessories.
The company showcases some of its creative work and skilled in-house graphic designers on its web page.
Printful vs Printify Quality
This part is one that the most differs from typical Printful reviews. Usually, reading Printful reviews, it looks like they have the best product quality on the market.
But that’s because often, people who write Printful reviews are nothing more than Printful’s affiliates. Or, perhaps, they worked with them during the start of Printful’s success and simply recalled it as the greatest. At present, they either don’t operate at all or haven’t tested anybody other than Printful.
Do not take my word for it; instead, join the Printful Insiders Facebook community and see for yourself what Printful’s famous product quality is all about.
The Printify print quality is decent, and I have received no serious complaints from customers regarding the quality of Printify products.
Printify vs Printful Conclusion
As I said above, both of these platforms are flagships of the print-on-demand industry, both have their pros and cons, and you have to decide who you want to deal with. I hope this Printful vs Printify review will help you make the right choice!